Exploring the Real Deal: Low Carb Cheesecakes Uncovered
Written on
Introduction to Low Carb Cheesecakes
A recent text from a client caught my attention: "Absolutely, 100% worth it! And probably too good to be true. I hope you don't crush my dreams when you read the label." As a health coach, my role involves guiding clients not just in their dietary choices but in their overall lifestyle, including physical activity and self-perception. While some may perceive me as overly critical, this client's lighthearted comment raised a valid question about Wonder Monday Low Carb Cheesecakes. Even though I’m not particularly fond of cheesecake, such enthusiasm sparked my curiosity.
Investigating the Claims
I explored their website to assess their promotional statements. They advertise their cheesecakes as being low in carbohydrates, high in protein, and gluten-free, boldly claiming they are "impossibly delicious." However, the ultimate verdict on taste is yours to decide. Here, we will focus on the nutritional aspects.
Analyzing Nutritional Information
Focusing on their classic plain cheesecake, I noted it boasts only 3 grams of net carbs, which initially grabbed my interest. Each serving contains 270 calories, 24 grams of fat (with 12 grams classified as saturated fat), and 10 grams of protein—comparable to just over an ounce or slightly more than an egg. A deeper dive into the carbohydrate content reveals 28 grams of total carbs, 1 gram of fiber, 2 grams of sugar, 0 grams of sugar alcohols, and a substantial 24 grams of allulose. The calculation of net carbs subtracts fiber from total carbs, resulting in 27 grams, and then removes allulose to yield 3 grams of net carbs.
Understanding Allulose
Before we revisit the fat content, let's delve into allulose. This relatively new, low-calorie sweetener is FDA-approved, yet research surrounding it remains limited. Current studies indicate that allulose is not absorbed by the body and is instead expelled through urine, meaning it doesn’t elevate blood sugar levels or impact insulin—key factors in its exclusion from the net carb count. However, the significant quantity of allulose in these cheesecakes—24 grams—raises some eyebrows. Most research has focused on doses between 4 and 7 grams, with the highest being 15 grams. The long-term effects of such high doses are still unknown, and short-term reactions can include bloating or diarrhea. While allulose may not spike blood sugar, it can still incite cravings for sugar, potentially leading to fluctuations in blood sugar levels. While these cheesecakes may be a less harmful option for occasional snacking, whole fruits would undoubtedly be a healthier choice. It's essential to approach anything that may trigger sweetness cravings with caution, particularly in light of the widespread issues with blood sugar regulation.
Evaluating the Fat Content
The total fat content of 24 grams is noteworthy, especially with half of that being saturated fat, which raises another concern for me. To gain a clearer understanding of the sources of fat and the overall makeup, I examined the ingredients list. For the classic plain cheesecake, the ingredients include pasteurized cultured milk and cream, with allulose listed as the second ingredient. The list continues with eggs, almond flour, milk protein, coconut and/or sustainable palm fruit oil, cream, vanilla, crystallized lemon, cinnamon, salt, and less than 2% of carob and guar gum, stevia, and natural flavors. The fat primarily derives from milk, cream, coconut, and palm fruit oil, which are not viewed as the healthiest fat sources. According to one of my mentors, saturated fats found in coconut products may interfere with insulin receptor sites, affecting insulin utilization for those managing blood sugar issues.
Concerns and Considerations
From my perspective, there are two significant concerns regarding this cheesecake alternative. I also wanted to explore the other flavors because it’s important to note that the nutritional content of one flavor cannot be indiscriminately applied to others. Generally, they were similar; for instance, the strawberry flavor contained no added sugar and had 1 gram less of allulose. While the ingredients were primarily the same, the inclusion of strawberries was a pleasant surprise (as many processed foods use artificial flavors instead). Other additions included tapioca flour and tomato extract for coloring. They also provide flavors like key lime pie, chocolate, and espresso, each with minor variations. The double chocolate flavor, for example, had slightly higher protein and fiber, but these differences were not substantial enough to alleviate my concerns.
While these cheesecakes present a tantalizing alternative to traditional desserts that are detrimental to health, their high fat content and excessive allulose warrant caution. Consuming them occasionally and in moderation may help satisfy cravings without significant issues. Nevertheless, it is crucial to maintain a balanced approach to nutrition by focusing on protein, fiber, and healthy fats in meals. Although not ideal for everyone, these cheesecakes may cater to specific tastes and scenarios.
Final Thoughts
I’d like to add a final note: while they may be a better dessert option, let's refrain from labeling them as health foods! Considering dairy's inflammatory potential, egg sensitivity issues, and portion sizes, it’s clear that these choices are not necessarily health-enhancing. Recognizing this distinction can help clarify their position within the realm of dessert options. Ultimately, whether to keep them in your fridge depends on individual preferences, dietary restrictions, and health objectives. As always, I encourage you to make well-informed choices that align with your overall lifestyle.