The Enduring Legacy of Tooth Removal in Ancient Taiwan
Written on
Chapter 1: Introduction to Dental Ablation
In 2016, a visit to the dentist revealed an issue with my wisdom teeth. The skin above them wasn't receding as expected, causing painful chewing. My dentist proposed a simple solution: cut away the excess skin. Despite the potential for future alignment issues with my front tooth, we opted for removal instead of risking ongoing discomfort. After a successful surgery, I woke up to find my four healthy wisdom teeth in a small container—a rather peculiar but memorable memento. Fortunately, my recovery was quick and relatively painless.
Dental ablation—the intentional removal of healthy teeth—has been a practice in numerous cultures worldwide. My own experience was influenced by both medical necessity and aesthetic considerations. In ancient Taiwan, the removal of certain front teeth has been practiced for thousands of years, originating with the first Austronesian communities and eventually spreading throughout the Asia-Pacific region. However, a thorough exploration of how and why this practice emerged and persisted has only recently gained attention.
Chapter 2: Research Findings
A recent study led by archaeologist Yue Zhang and her team delves into tooth ablation in Taiwan, tracing its roots back over 4,800 years. The research aims to bridge gaps in understanding the origins and evolution of this practice and its role in shaping both individual and communal identities.
To achieve this, the researchers meticulously analyzed over 1,300 reports and documents from more than 250 archaeological sites containing the remains of individuals who had undergone tooth ablation. A thorough ethnographic record was also compiled, highlighting the cultural and social justifications for this practice among indigenous Austronesian groups in Taiwan.
Section 2.1: Historical Context of Tooth Removal
Taiwan's prehistoric timeline can be divided into three key periods: the Palaeolithic (30,000-4,800 BP), Neolithic (4,800–2,400 BP), and Iron Age (2,400–400 BP). The earliest evidence of human habitation in Taiwan dates to the Palaeolithic era, while intentional burials appeared around 6,000 BP. By 4,800 BP, the Neolithic era began, characterized by the introduction of new pottery styles, settled communities, domesticated animals, and the earliest instances of tooth ablation.
This tradition likely originated from the Middle Yangtze region, spreading to the southern coasts of China and eventually reaching Taiwan. Archaeological evidence indicates that tooth removal was a deliberate act among Neolithic Austronesian groups. Healthy individuals with evidence of tooth ablation suggest that this practice was not due to disease or injury but was a conscious choice. Typically, the teeth removed were incisors and canines, following specific patterns observed across genders.
The first video provides insights into how ancient people in Taiwan engaged in tooth removal, emphasizing both aesthetic preferences and cultural significance.
Section 2.2: Gender Dynamics in Tooth Ablation
Interestingly, studies of preserved skeletal remains indicate that the practice of tooth ablation became less common among males around 3,300 BP. This shift coincided with changes in burial customs, suggesting a broader cultural transformation. By 1,900 BP, the practice had largely become exclusive to females.
Current evidence suggests that southern Taiwan showcases the strongest continuity of tooth ablation traditions, likely due to better preservation conditions. However, understanding why this practice declined in other regions and became more female-centric requires further investigation.
The second video explores modern studies revealing how ancient Taiwanese people yanked teeth for beauty and courage, shedding light on the cultural significance of these practices.
Chapter 3: Ethnographic Insights into Tooth Removal
Archaeology offers valuable insights into the when and where of tooth ablation practices, but ethnographic accounts provide context for the why. Some of the earliest records come from ancient Chinese texts, while more comprehensive accounts emerged from surveys during the Japanese occupation of Taiwan.
Today, Taiwan recognizes sixteen indigenous Austronesian-speaking groups, with nine documented to have practiced tooth removal as late as the mid-20th century. These accounts reveal varying practices and social meanings behind tooth ablation, illustrating a more balanced distribution of the practice across genders in modern times.
Tooth removal methods varied by region, with northern groups typically using striking techniques and southern groups favoring pulling methods. The traumatic nature of these procedures often led to infections, prompting communities to conduct extractions during specific festivals to minimize risks.
The motivations for tooth ablation were multifaceted. Aesthetic preferences drove individuals to seek a more appealing appearance, while practical reasons included addressing dental issues and aiding in speech. Additionally, tooth ablation served as a rite of passage, reflecting bravery and distinguishing tribal members.
Chapter 4: Cultural Continuity and Transformation
Despite changes in cultural significance over time, tooth ablation remained prevalent in many indigenous cultures across the Austronesian world, extending from Taiwan to regions such as Borneo and Hawaii. As the practice spread, its meaning evolved; some groups opted for alternatives like tooth blackening or filing rather than removal.
Yue Zhang and her colleagues' recent research illuminates the complexities of this ancient tradition, tracing its origins and cultural meanings throughout history. While motivations for tooth removal have shifted—from aesthetic desires to rites of passage—the practice has remained a significant aspect of many indigenous cultures for millennia.
As I reflect on my own painless dental experience, I can't help but appreciate the historical significance of tooth ablation. What are your thoughts on this practice? Why do you think the prevalence among males decreased only to resurface later? Feel free to share your insights, and if you're interested in supporting my work, consider buying me a coffee!