The Dangers of Restrictive Sexual Laws: A Threat to Women's Safety
Written on
Chapter 1: The Impact of Sexual Law Restrictions
In recent years, I have hosted "The Science of Sex," where I’ve engaged with insightful guests, innovative researchers, and psychologists, all delving into the complexities of modern sexuality. Navigating this landscape has become increasingly challenging, especially as discussions around sex and pornography remain highly contentious.
As time progresses, a vocal minority that opposes sexual freedom in the United States appears to grow bolder. The introduction of porn ID verification laws, which compel pornographic websites to require age verification, exemplifies this trend. States enforcing these laws are not limited to targeting adult content; they also aim at platforms like Facebook and Medium, which host a variety of non-pornographic material.
These laws effectively act as bans on porn, disguised under the guise of protecting minors. By using terms such as "harmful to minors," they encompass a wide range of content beyond just pornography, often criminalizing LGBTQ+ resources and other non-adult sites. This represents an overreach of governmental power that infringes on free speech rights.
Now is an opportune moment to revisit existing data—both historical and contemporary—that highlights the dangers of these restrictions.
While pornographic platforms agree on the importance of preventing minors from accessing their content, they recognize that these laws do not effectively shield children; rather, they hinder adults from using these platforms responsibly. Politicians who champion these laws may celebrate their achievements, but the reality is more troubling: empirical studies indicate that the prohibition of sex work, whether online or in-person, often correlates with an uptick in sexual crimes against women.
Ironically, many women opposed to pornography often cite concerns about its potential to incite sexual violence—violence either against performers or against women in their lives whose partners consume pornographic material. However, research suggests that this belief is largely unfounded.
A positive trend emerges from the data: when restrictions on sexual expression are relaxed, there tends to be a decrease in sexual assault incidents. Unfortunately, numerous states in the U.S. are determined to impose stricter limitations on sexuality, setting a concerning precedent that other nations might follow.
New Insights on Sexual Violence and Pornography
Recent research by Riccardo Ciacci, published in the Journal of Population Economics on March 14, 2024, reinforces long-held beliefs regarding pornography and its relationship with sexual violence. Notably, the study indicates that not only does pornography not contribute to violence, but it may, in fact, reduce rates of sexual aggression. A significant new angle in this research is the relationship between legalized sex work and sexual violence.
Ciacci’s examination of rape statistics in Sweden from 1997 to 2014 reveals troubling outcomes following the criminalization of sex work in 1999. The data shows that the ban resulted in a staggering increase in reported rapes, by approximately 44% to 62%. Furthermore, the rate of pimps did not decline, suggesting that individuals who once hired sex workers may have resorted to committing sexual violence instead.
Some may argue that this rise in reported rapes could be attributed to sex workers not previously reporting their assaults; however, this assumption is flawed. As UCLA neuroscientist Nicole Prause argues, the premise that sex workers do not report assaults does not hold, especially given that their profession was legal prior to the ban.
To illustrate, if marijuana were legal, one would expect theft of marijuana to be reported frequently; criminalizing it would likely decrease those reports. If the theft rate remained unchanged, it would indicate that the criminalization did not impact reporting behavior.
This analogy underscores the fact that the rise in rapes following the ban in Sweden is likely not a consequence of reporting discrepancies.
The Relationship Between Pornography and Violence at Home
Scientific evidence consistently indicates that the prohibition of sex work and pornography leads to an increase in crimes against women. Conversely, the legalization of these practices has been linked to a reduction in sexual violence.
Take the case of the Czech Republic: once communism collapsed in the early 1990s, porn was legalized, resulting in a near 50% drop in sexual violence. This trend is not isolated; it has been observed in various countries worldwide. Contrary to fears that access to pornography would escalate violence, studies have shown no increase in sexual crimes in any nation that has legalized porn.
A 1991 study examining pornography’s influence in Sweden, Denmark, Germany, and the United States concluded that the rise of pornography did not correlate with increased rates of rape. Instead, as the porn industry expanded, sexual violence rates decreased.
In the U.S., the surge in access to pornography through the internet has coincided with a significant decline in sexual assault rates—down 44% since 1995, according to the National Crime Victimization Survey.
The Role of Hostile Masculinity
Population-level studies provide invaluable insights, as individual-level data can only suggest correlations without establishing causality. For instance, a 2020 study by Taylor Kohut et al. examined the relationship between porn use and violent tendencies among teenage boys in Croatia. Their findings revealed that while hostile masculinity correlated with sexual aggression, neither porn consumption nor impersonal sexual attitudes were predictors of aggressive behavior.
As noted by David Ludden, Ph.D., hostile masculinity does not inherently drive men to act out sexually aggressive behavior. Many men may harbor frustrations and engage with violent pornographic content without translating those desires into real-life actions.
To summarize, there is scant evidence linking porn use directly to sexual violence. This situation parallels the discussion surrounding video games: just as most players of violent games do not replicate those behaviors, most porn consumers do not engage in sexual violence.
The Causality Dilemma
A 2000 study involving women at rape crisis centers aimed to investigate the connection between porn and violence. Surprisingly, it found that only 28% of women reported their abusers had consumed pornography, raising significant questions about the theory that porn consumption leads to sexual aggression.
If 100 alcoholics in rehab were examined and only 28% had consumed alcohol, this would challenge the notion that drinking causes addiction. The same logic applies to porn.
An Examination of Industry Practices
Criticism of the porn industry often falls into two categories: unfounded claims without empirical support or misconceptions based on outdated practices. For instance, statements like "porn is addictive" or "all porn is rape" are demonstrably false. Conversely, some criticisms may have once been valid but are no longer applicable, particularly regarding performer consent.
Chloe Cherry, an adult film performer, has discussed the use of consent checklists in the industry, which outline what acts performers are comfortable with. These checklists ensure that consent is prioritized before filming begins, a practice that many may not be aware of.
Today, the landscape of porn has transformed; it is no longer a male-dominated industry. With advancements in technology, individuals can create and distribute their content independently, diminishing the power imbalances that once characterized the industry.
Concerns about increasing violence in porn are also unfounded. Research from 2018 indicates that consumer preferences are shifting towards non-violent content, leading to a decrease in violent porn.
The Repeal of Sodomy Laws and Their Effects
Recent findings by Riccardo Ciacci and Dario Sansone suggest that repealing sodomy laws correlates with a decline in arrests for various non-sodomy-related offenses, including sex work and drug-related crimes. Their research implies that these laws often facilitate a wider net of law enforcement, targeting marginalized communities.
The evidence suggests that criminalizing sexual expression leads to increased societal tensions and violence, as individuals may resort to alternative outlets when their sexual needs are suppressed.
Final Thoughts
This discussion does not advocate for unrestricted sexual freedom without limits; there are moral considerations, particularly concerning non-consensual acts. However, the evidence is clear: the choice between legal porn and increased sexual violence is not a difficult one.
Individuals are entitled to their personal discomfort with porn, but banning it entirely is not the solution. This approach echoes a misguided response to music censorship; it is ineffective and counterproductive, often leading to higher rates of sexual assault.
In essence, non-consensual violence should never be a consequence of prohibiting consensual sexual practices, including porn and sex work. It is not our role to dictate the choices of others concerning their bodies.
Thanks for engaging with this content. For more insights on human sexuality through the lens of science, consider subscribing to "The Science of Sex" on Substack.
This video discusses the challenges faced by survivors of sexual and intimate partner violence within the criminal justice system.
An exploration of violence and sexual assault against women in the context of sex trafficking, highlighting prevention strategies.