<The Case Against Calling Others Talented: A Deeper Look at Skill>
Written on
In recent discussions, a provocative idea has emerged: calling someone “talented” can be dismissive.
At first glance, it seems harmless. Many of us aspire to be recognized for our talents, believing it to be the highest form of praise, especially for artists or athletes. However, the term “talented” often overlooks the hard work and dedication that go into mastering a skill.
I learned this lesson personally when I praised my partner, Larry, for his guitar skills. After watching him effortlessly play a song from Coco, I remarked, “You’re so talented.” In that moment, my compliment felt more like a complaint than an acknowledgment of his hard work.
The Meaning Behind “Talented”
To understand the implications of calling someone talented, let’s look at its definition. According to the Oxford Dictionary, “talented” is described as possessing a natural skill or aptitude for something. Synonyms include “gifted,” “skilled,” and “expert.” The common understanding is that talent is something one is born with, rather than something one earns through effort. This perspective can undermine the countless hours dedicated to honing a craft.
What We Imply When We Use “Talented”
Consider the last time you referred to someone as talented. Perhaps you were moved by their music or impressed by their performance. Did you genuinely believe they achieved their skill without effort? Likely not, yet that’s the implication of the word “talented.”
The Underestimated Effort Behind Mastery
While it may seem flattering to call someone talented, it can also unintentionally minimize the hard work they’ve put in. Although my initial use of the word was well-intentioned, it sparked a thoughtful conversation about the significance of perseverance and dedication in developing skills.
Larry, who has spent nearly twenty-five years learning guitar, often emphasizes that mastery requires time and commitment. His journey illustrates that the perception of talent often overlooks the struggle and discipline required to reach such levels.
The Challenge of Language and Expression
As technology advances, our vocabulary seems to dwindle. Many of us resort to basic compliments like “talented,” which can feel hollow after repeated use. During my time working at a music venue, I often found myself relying on this overused term to express appreciation, failing to articulate what truly resonated with me about each performance.
Learning to articulate specific praises not only honors the artist’s effort but also enriches our own experiences of art.
The Journey of Learning: It’s Never Too Late
Larry and I recently embarked on a new adventure of learning Spanish. This endeavor serves as a reminder that it’s never too late to gain new skills. With countless resources available online, anyone can pursue knowledge in various fields, from languages to hobbies.
The takeaway is clear: rather than lamenting a lack of talent, we should embrace the learning process and appreciate the journey of growth.
A New Approach to Compliments
Instead of defaulting to “talented,” strive to express what you specifically admire about someone’s work. This approach fosters deeper connections and acknowledges the effort behind their craft.
Ultimately, appreciating the hard work and perseverance that goes into mastery is more meaningful than simply labeling someone as talented.
In a world overflowing with potential, remember that the only limits to your growth are the ones you impose on yourself.