Chapter 1: The State of Historical Knowledge in America

It is a well-known fact that many Americans lack a solid understanding of history, often reflected in troubling statistics. Regular surveys reveal that a significant portion of the population is unaware of key historical events. For instance, a substantial number of Americans fail to recognize that the Civil War occurred after the Revolutionary War, and nearly 80% of college graduates struggle to accurately describe the Emancipation Proclamation. This indicates a concerning absence of a coherent historical narrative among Americans.

Despite frequent debates about the interpretation of our history, many individuals lack sufficient factual knowledge to contribute meaningfully to these discussions. For example, only 29% of students at the nation’s top colleges can identify what Reconstruction was, which hampers our ability to engage in informed discourse about its significance.

While this lack of awareness is alarming, I believe the core issue lies deeper: many Americans do not grasp what history truly is or how it is constructed by historians. To understand this better, let's examine the types of historical material Americans typically engage with.

Next time you visit your local library or bookstore, take a moment to browse the "History" section. You will likely encounter a plethora of books focusing on wars (particularly the Civil War and World War II), biographies of presidents, and a smattering of self-help literature masquerading as history. In the "World History" subsection, you may find more on World War II, a handful of works about European royalty, and perhaps a few titles exploring current global tensions, such as the rise of China. Unfortunately, much of the rich tapestry of human history is absent from these shelves.

Realistically, most Americans do not read history books at all. Many receive their historical education through television or films. However, the variety of content is still limited. When I search for "historical documentaries" on platforms like Netflix, I am often met with a barrage of World War II content, royal family dramas, and pop culture explorations.

The internet offers some intriguing historical content through podcasts and YouTube channels, but much of it tends to focus on minute details of specific conflicts. The majority of historical narratives available to Americans fit into familiar categories (wars, royalty, etc.) and are designed to capture the attention of an audience with a short attention span. Consuming this type of media allows viewers to feel intellectually fulfilled, even if the knowledge gained is superficial.

What, then, do we truly learn from this consumption? As a long-time history educator, I often dread conversations with self-proclaimed "history buffs." Typically, they want to discuss battles or films about World War II, topics I find less engaging. Many Americans mistakenly equate being a historian with being an avid history enthusiast, assuming that we spend our days memorizing battles and the quirks of historical figures. However, this misconception misses the essence of what it means to study history.

A history buff may know the names of all the vice presidents or the divisions involved in a particular battle. In contrast, historians frequently need to look up these details because their focus lies not in memorization but in understanding broader trends, causes, effects, and societal structures.

To illustrate this distinction further, consider that a history buff often becomes more confident in their knowledge as they learn more, while a true historian recognizes the vastness of what remains unknown. The study of history, when done correctly, is a humbling pursuit. It involves looking through a murky lens at people who may resemble us in many ways but are also vastly different. Piecing together the past often requires navigating fragmentary and sometimes contradictory evidence, leading to a deeper appreciation of its complexity.

While I would love for Americans to grasp the basic facts of their history, I believe the more pressing issue is their lack of understanding of what it means to study history. Politicians and commentators frequently assert that "history tells us" this or that without truly comprehending the nuances involved. This misunderstanding is prevalent across the political spectrum, as both sides often seek to mold history to reinforce their beliefs or agendas.

The tendency to simplify historical narratives for political gain is not confined to history alone; it extends to other fields such as science and economics. In contentious scientific debates, such as those surrounding climate change or COVID-19, Americans often struggle to accept complex, uncertain information. We tend to prefer neat, digestible stories that align with our pre-existing beliefs.

Engaging deeply with a subject often leads to a greater comfort with uncertainty. As we investigate further, we uncover more questions and become aware of evidence gaps and counterarguments. This aligns with the philosophical notion that true wisdom lies in recognizing the limits of our knowledge.

However, once history enters the public discourse, it frequently gets distilled and simplified, making it more palatable for entertainment or political purposes. This reductionism is unfortunate, as it robs most Americans of a nuanced understanding of the past.

Experiencing the challenge of grasping what life was like in vastly different societies can be a humbling endeavor. It encourages us to confront our misplaced certainties about the world. I wish more individuals had the opportunity to think critically like historians do.

In this video, Dr. Christopher Perrin discusses the implications of our collective ignorance of history and how it shapes our perception of current events.

Chapter 2: The Consequences of Historical Ignorance

This video explores how America's historical ignorance contributes to a culture of misunderstanding and poor decision-making, emphasizing the need for a more informed populace.

Thanks for reading! If you’d like to receive updates when I publish new articles, please subscribe here. Your support would mean a lot to me, whether by buying me a coffee or joining Medium through my link, which allows me to earn a portion of your membership fee at no extra cost to you.