Innovative Insomnia Solutions: Breaking Free from Sleep Myths
Written on
Challenging the Sleep Norm
The traditional belief in the necessity of eight uninterrupted hours of sleep is under scrutiny. This perspective has been shown to be unnatural, especially considering that around 30% of adults continue to struggle with insomnia despite conventional remedies.
The implications of recognizing midnight wakefulness as a sleep disorder could be detrimental. Meanwhile, the media often overlooks the surprisingly effective approach of "micro-dosing" exercise during nighttime wakefulness.
In this guide, a scientist who once battled insomnia shares a practical framework for effectively managing those dreaded sleepless nights.
Media Sleep Advice: A Flawed Approach
For years, I've been drawn to sensational articles like "32 Tips for a Better Bedtime Routine" from Woman & Home or "The Holy Grail of Sleep Tips" from CNN. These pieces often emphasize the dire consequences of not adhering to the 8-hour sleep ideal, only to recycle the same tired solutions. Techniques like sleep hygiene, silk pillows, and lavender oils did little to alleviate my anxiety-driven insomnia. It wasn't until I started to challenge these established beliefs that I discovered two key insights.
First, our ancestors thrived on segmented sleep rather than a single uninterrupted block. Second, engaging in paradoxically effective activities during these wakeful periods can be the best remedy. I will elaborate on these points shortly and question why sleep and wellness experts have yet to acknowledge them.
Rethinking the 8-Hour Sleep Myth
"Discovery consists of seeing what everybody has seen and thinking what nobody has thought." — Albert von Szent-Györgyi
In my scientific journey, I’ve learned that the most fascinating insights arise from questioning widely accepted truths. Naturally, the 8-hour sleep doctrine was my first target. Notably, Roger Ekirch, a distinguished history professor at Virginia Tech, has explored historical sleep patterns. He argues that segmented sleep was the norm for pre-industrial European societies, consisting of a "first sleep" and a "second sleep," separated by a 1–2 hour period of wakefulness during which people would engage in various activities, such as chatting or household chores.
These insights suggest that segmented sleep is a natural occurrence rather than a disorder, as supported by evidence across various cultures and eras. However, some critics, like Verhoeven, have challenged this view, pointing out a lack of evidence for segmented sleep in 19th-century Antwerp.
Nonetheless, a recent review on the "Human Sleep Paradox" acknowledges the diverse sleep habits of humans and questions why the topic of "natural" sleep patterns has only recently gained attention. Regardless of where you stand on this debate, it’s wise to be cautious about hastily labeling midnight insomnia as a disorder.
I found myself unconsciously adopting this pre-industrial approach to nighttime productivity. If I was unable to sleep, I would work on my research, and within a couple of hours, I could drift off more easily than if I had remained idle in bed.
Your first takeaway: Don’t stress about losing sleep, as worrying about it only exacerbates insomnia. Instead, consider utilizing that time productively.
The Surprising Benefits of Nighttime Exercise
Clearly, brewing beer or chopping wood at midnight isn't everyone's solution to insomnia. To delve deeper, I examined a special group of professionals who must return to sleep quickly after nighttime duties—firefighters, paramedics, and hospital staff. In Europe, about one in five workers report having on-call responsibilities, which vary significantly by country.
These professionals need to respond to emergencies and return to sleep swiftly, making sleep inertia—a transitional state between sleep and alertness—minimized. Therefore, I anticipated valuable research on how these workers manage sleep disruptions.
Interestingly, most studies focus on how exercise timing throughout the day affects health and sleep, but there is a lack of research on short bursts of exercise during sleep interruptions. This absence was unexpected, as the neurohormonal pathways linking brief physical activity to mood, pain, and alertness are well-established.
I began "self-medicating" my insomnia with 5 minutes of high-intensity exercise during wakeful periods. Following my intuition, I discovered that a 2021 study explored how a short bout of exercise after awakening influenced subsequent sleep.
The study involved a 2-minute warm-up followed by 30 seconds of moderate- to high-intensity cycling, with results showing increased sleep duration and improved sleep efficiency.
Understanding Sleep Metrics
Sleep metrics like N3 latency—how quickly one transitions from wakefulness to deep sleep—and sleep efficiency—the ratio of actual sleep time to total time in bed—are crucial. For instance, if you spend 8 hours in bed but only sleep for 7, your sleep efficiency is 87.5%.
Given the brevity of the exercise (just 2.5 minutes), the results are remarkable. Emergency personnel can’t afford lengthy workouts before duty, but insomniacs have no such constraints. Even adding a minute or two might enhance the benefits.
Your second takeaway: Embrace the counterintuitive advantages of exercise to facilitate falling back asleep.
The Science Behind Brief Exercise
If anxiety or stress fuels your insomnia, brief bouts of exercise can trigger neurotransmitters and hormones that combat these feelings.
- Serotonin: This neurotransmitter plays a crucial role in promoting sleep, and short exercises have been found to enhance its activity.
- Endocannabinoids: These compounds positively influence mood, and moderate exercise has been shown to increase their levels more effectively than low- or high-intensity workouts.
- Endorphins: Known for elevating mood and alleviating anxiety, endorphins are boosted by even brief, intense exercise.
Viewing Nighttime Wakefulness as an Opportunity
For years, I relied on sleeping pills during nighttime awakenings, resigned to the idea that sleep would evade me. However, I realized that treating insomnia with lifestyle changes rather than medication was a more empowering approach.
Reframing these nighttime disruptions as opportunities for productivity helped alleviate my worries. Engaging in work during the night not only calmed my mind but also made it easier to return to sleep.
When I recognized that brief exercise could activate my neurohormonal system, I began to experiment with it. I discovered that performing two isometric exercises—a plank and a wall squat—each to exhaustion, often helped me return to sleep quickly.
If you’d like to try incorporating exercise into your routine, experiment with activities that suit you. Whether it’s a few minutes of moderate cycling or a quick workout, find what works best for you.
Ultimately, I found these strategies—dismissing the 8-hour sleep myth and embracing the paradoxical effects of nighttime exercise—much more effective than the recycled advice from self-proclaimed sleep experts.
Gone are the days of following the same advice with disappointing outcomes. I’ve also liberated myself from the alarm clock, waking naturally around 5 a.m. without stress about sleeping in.
Let me know how you navigate your insomnia, and if you try my suggestions, share your results. The community of insomniacs is vast, and we all could benefit from shared experiences.
In this video titled "Insomnia- How to Fall Asleep When your Brain Won't Shut Up!", discover strategies to quiet your mind and promote restful sleep.
The second video, "What to do when you go through an endless cycle of bad sleep followed by better sleep," offers insights for breaking the sleep cycle and achieving restful nights.